Reconsideration of pre-appeal decisions

Notion(s) Filing Case
Decision on Motions to Present Additional Evidence - 07.07.2005 NALETILIĆ & MARTINOVIĆ

20.    The Appeals Chamber endorses the position of the ICTR Appeals Chamber that “the Appeals Chamber ordinarily treats its prior interlocutory decisions as binding in continued proceedings in the same case as to all issues definitively decided by those decisions” in order to “allow certain issues to be finally resolved before proceedings continue on other issues.” The only exception to this principle is that the Appeals Chamber may “reconsider a previous interlocutory decision under its ‘inherent discretionary power’ to do so ‘if a clear error of reasoning has been demonstrated or if it is necessary to do so to prevent an injustice.’” This exception allows the Appeals Chamber a “meaningful opportunity” to “correct any mistakes it has made.” The Appeals Chamber finds that this same principle and exception are applicable to its pre-appeal decisions on motions filed before the Appeals Chamber prior to the appeals hearing. […]

[1] Kajelijeli v. The Prosecutor, Case No. ICTR-98-44A-A, Judgement, 23 May 2005, para. 202.

[2] Ibid., para. 203 (internal citation omitted).

[3] Ibid.

[4] Cf. Nahimana et al., Case No. ICTR-99-52-A, Decision on Jean-Bosco Baryagwiza’s Request for Reconsideration of Appeals Chamber Decision of 19 January 2005, 4 February 2005 (denying the Appellant’s request for reconsideration of the Appeals Chamber’s pre-appeal decision on appointment of counsel). The Appeals Chamber notes that the Rules and Practice Directions of the International Tribunal distinguish between interlocutory appeal and pre-appeal decisions by the Appeals Chamber. Interlocutory appeals are generally filed before the Appeals Chamber under Rules 72 and 73 when a case is at trial against a Trial Chamber’s interlocutory decision prior to the issuance of the trial judgement. On the other hand, pre-appeal decisions are those made on motions, such as Rule 115 motions, filed before the Appeals Chamber when a case is already on appeal and pending before the Appeals Chamber. See generally Practice Direction on Procedure for the Filing of Written Submissions in Appeal Proceedings Before the International Tribunal (IT/155 Rev. 2), 21 February 2005.

Download full document